Comparison
AutoRelay vs CarGurus
CarGurus promotes price transparency that trains shoppers to negotiate harder. AutoRelay gives you leverage — exclusive access to your own customers' vehicles.
CarGurus built its brand on showing consumers the "best deals" — which means your margin is under pressure before the customer even walks in. AutoRelay takes a different approach: instead of competing on price in a public marketplace, you're acquiring vehicles from customers who already service with you, at fair market value, without negotiation pressure from competing offers.
Feature-by-Feature Comparison
Lead Exclusivity
AutoRelay
Exclusive — your own service customers
CarGurus
Shared marketplace leads
Cost Per Lead
AutoRelay
Flat monthly fee — unlimited leads
CarGurus
$25-$50 per lead + dealer dashboard fee
Price Pressure
AutoRelay
Private conversation — no public pricing
CarGurus
"Great Deal" badges push prices down
Margin Protection
AutoRelay
Acquire at fair market value, no bidding wars
CarGurus
Consumers trained to expect the lowest price
AI Response Time
AutoRelay
Under 5 seconds, 24/7
CarGurus
No dealer-side AI
Vehicle Knowledge
AutoRelay
Full service history from DMS integration
CarGurus
Only VIN-based listing data
Customer Relationship
AutoRelay
Existing service customer (built-in trust)
CarGurus
Anonymous shopper (no prior relationship)
Contract
AutoRelay
Month-to-month, cancel anytime
CarGurus
Annual contracts common
Why Dealers Switch to AutoRelay
- 1
CarGurus' price transparency is great for consumers — but it trains buyers to negotiate harder, compressing your margins on every deal.
- 2
Instead of competing for internet shoppers on price, capture vehicles from your service lane where you have the relationship advantage and full vehicle history.
- 3
AutoRelay customers aren't comparison shopping — they're getting an offer from a dealership they already trust, at a price that protects your margin.
Ready to Acquire More Vehicles for Less?
Free for 30 days. No credit card. No contracts. Live in 10 minutes.